He currently plays for Indy Eleven, wearing the number 17 shirt. He plays primarily as a Defender. His current market value is estimated at 100K €.

His most recent move was a from Indiana Fire Academy to Indy Eleven on 2024-10-09.

Throughout the USL Championship 2025, Logan Neidlinger featured in 2 matches, averaging 0.5 tackles, 0 interceptions, and 0 clearances per game, while blocking 0 shots per game.